Plot
Straitlaced Princeton University admissions officer Portia Nathan is caught off-guard when she makes a recruiting visit to an alternative high school overseen by her former classmate, the freewheeling John Pressman. Pressman has surmised that Jeremiah, his gifted yet very unconventional student, might well be the son that Portia secretly gave up for adoption many years ago.
Trailer
Cast
Tina Fey
Portia Nathan
Ann Harada
Mrs. Lafont
Ben Levin
Junior Lafont
Dan Levy
James
Maggie Keenan-Bolger
Girl on Tour
Gloria Reuben
Corinne
Paul Rudd
John Pressman
Wallace Shawn
Clarence
Elaine Kussack
Abby
Christopher Evan Welch
Brandt
Michael Genadry
Ben
Juliet Brett
Praying Applicant
John Brodsky
Smug Kid
Camille Branton
Gymnast
Sarita Choudhury
Rachael
Michael Sheen
Mark
Ken Barnett
Admissions Counselor
Nat Wolff
Jeremiah
Travis Bratten
Quest Student
Tanisha Long
Quest Student
Nadia Alexander
Quest Student
Karen Pham
Quest Student
Travaris Spears
Nelson
Lily Tomlin
Susannah
Rob Campbell
Richard
Sonya Walger
Helen
Olek Krupa
Polokov
Roby Sobieski
Makeout Guy
Lauren Schaffel
Student at Party
Brian Charles Johnson
Student at Party
Lipica Shah
Student at Party
Jarod Einsohn
Keg Guy
Caliaf St. Aubyn
Keg Guy's Friend
Zita Geoffroy
Tour Group Mom
Laura Jordan
Woman
Zachary Unger
Jeremiah - 8 Years Old
Lisa Emery
Mrs. Pressman
Mihran Slougian
Jeremiah's Dad
Lynne Taylor
Jeremiah's Mom
Brian d'Arcy James
Christopher Flynn
Leigha Hancock
Yulia Karasov
Sarah Quinn
Young Mother
Jason Blaj
Supermarket Kid
David Simins
A Capella Singer
Brad Wilson
A Capella Singer
Ryan McCarty
A Capella Singer
Krishna Choudhary
A Capella Singer
Ricky Jones
A Capella Singer
Thomas Merckens
A Capella Singer
Alan Robert Southworth
A Capella Singer
Chris Bronwell
A Capella Singer
Chris Palermo
A Capella Singer
Anthony Capers
Jeremiah's Buddy
Julia Faye Fisher
Agency Receptionist
Gameela Wright
Woman in Adoption Agency
James P. Anderson
Baxter Birthday Party Guest (uncredited)
Tina Benko
Andrea (uncredited)
Matthew Broadley
Twin Brother (uncredited)
Vanessa Carter
Quest Student (uncredited)
Alix Cross
Quest Student (uncredited)
Jonathon Culver
Quest Student (uncredited)
Giullian Yao Gioiello
Princeton Applicant (uncredited)
Brandon Lee Harris
Office Assistant (uncredited)
Alice Litvak
Twin Sister (uncredited)
Nicole Maggio
Lacrosse Girl (uncredited)
Alexis Molnar
Princeton College Applicant (uncredited)
Meaghan Monaghan
Student (uncredited)
Rachel Moss
Lacrosse Player (uncredited)
Ismaelpeter Casillas Nelson
Cow Milking Expert (uncredited)
Edward Sass III
Birthday Party Guest (uncredited)
Danielle Senk
Lacrosse Player (uncredited)
Natasha Tax
Prep School Girl (uncredited)
Barbara Vincent
Birthday Party Guest (uncredited)
Joshua Hinck
Sebastian
